
Agentic AI is one of the big themes at IP Service World this year. Renewal teams already work with a lot of technology: deadline tracking, dashboards, cost forecasting, and now AI that can review the work. Most of it is worth having.
In our work with IP teams, though, we’ve found that when renewals go wrong, a missing feature is seldom the reason. As Landon Teague, Chief Revenue Officer at Sun IP, explains in this article, more often, it’s the basics underneath the software. Was the data right? Did anyone know what was due and what it would cost? And when something unusual came up, was there someone on the other end who knew the portfolio?
A renewal looks like the most routine payment in IP, yet a single missed one can cost the right. After the grace period, getting it back depends on the office, and some set a high bar. Once those windows close, the right is gone for good.
Much of the difficulty is scale. A global portfolio doesn’t run on one calendar. Some offices charge every year, others at fixed intervals, and trademarks keep their own schedule. A European patent splits into national rights after validation, each with its own fees and grace period rules, while a Unitary Patent renews through the EPO. Get one date wrong in the source record and it can be wrong in several countries at once.
Often it isn’t carelessness. It’s the conditions people work in: data nobody has had time to check, systems that don’t talk to each other, costs that first appear on the invoice.
One of the riskiest assumptions in renewals is that the portfolio data is correct. Records pass between docketing systems, law firms, in-house teams and previous providers, and every handover is a chance for something to drift.
The errors tend to follow patterns. A due date gets calculated from grant when the office counts from filing. A national phase entry goes in without the right international filing date. A portfolio changes hands and the new owner is never recorded with the office. The mistake then travels with every export, and anything built on it, from reminders to cost forecasts, can inherit the error.
That’s why a one-time check isn’t enough. Good practice means verifying the dates behind each renewal against the official register wherever one is publicly available, treating a payment that can’t be confirmed as unpaid until payment is confirmed, and logging discrepancies so every correction gets a second look. It also means checking again when something changes, whether that’s a new filing, an assignment, a merger or a change of representation.
Most IP teams can say what’s in their portfolio. Fewer can say, on any given day, what’s due, what’s pending and what’s been paid. If the only way to find out is to email a provider or stitch spreadsheets together, the information exists, but it isn’t easy to act on.
Cost brings its own surprises. An invoice combines the official fee, any local agent fee, the provider’s fee and any currency conversion, plus a surcharge when paying in the grace period. Official fees change regularly, so a quote built on old rates can turn into a second invoice months later. For a corporate team, that can disrupt the budget. For a law firm, it can mean going back to a client with a revised bill.
Itemized quotes based on current official fees, with grace period costs shown up front, reduce much of that uncertainty. Locking a quote for a set period, even into the grace period, also takes currency swings out of the equation. They also make a harder conversation easier: which rights are still worth renewing.
It happens. An office changes a requirement. A client drops a country days before the deadline. A right needs reinstating. Those are the moments when the people behind the process matter.
What helps is someone who already knows the portfolio, rather than a ticket queue or a new contact who needs the history explained. Close to a deadline, a day lost to back-and-forth is a real risk.
Good support starts at onboarding. It should be quick, with clear milestones and a first payment date everyone has agreed on, and it should include the paralegals and administrators who handle renewals day to day. A setup tends to work better when it’s shaped by the people who use it.
There’s a lot to be optimistic about. AI can flag issues, sort records and take repetitive work off busy teams. But like every renewals tool, it depends on what it’s given. A reminder is right only if the date is right, and a forecast only if the costs are. An agent that instructs payments may act on the data in front of it without knowing whether anyone checked it.
In our experience, a good approach uses technology to surface problems and people to decide what to do about them.
Whether renewals are handled in-house or by a provider, three questions will tell you more than any feature comparison. How is the data checked? What will the renewals really cost? And who answers when something goes wrong? Munich is a good place to start asking them.
Sun IP is a leading provider of patent translation, foreign filing, and IP renewal solutions. We combine expert talent and cutting-edge technology to seamlessly support the global IP needs of law firms and corporate legal teams. Our core services, and powerful proprietary software platform, enable clients to control costs and more efficiently manage their global IP workflows.
No Comments